Pregnancy is an important milestone, but for many expectant employees, it can also raise significant concerns about their job security. A common question that arises is about pregnancy-related discrimination: Can my employer fire me if I’m pregnant? This is a crucial question, as the consequences of a wrongful dismissal during pregnancy or maternity leave can be financially devastating and emotionally distressing. In this article, we will explore the legal landscape surrounding pregnancy and maternity leave dismissals, as well as how pregnant employees can protect themselves from wrongful termination.
The Reality of Pregnancy-Related Dismissals
In Canada, employment law does offer certain protections for pregnant employees. However, that does mean they are immune from being dismissed by their employer. Many new parents who come to us for a legal consultation at our employment law firm are shocked to learn that their termination, while seemingly unfair, may not necessarily be illegal. The bottom line is this: an employer is generally permitted to terminate an employee – even while they are on a maternity leave – as long as the reason for doing so is not in any way connected to their pregnancy or maternity leave.
When an employee is terminated after disclosing her pregnancy, or while on or returning from maternity leave, it adds an extra layer of emotional and financial distress. Pregnancy is already a time of significant change, and being fired only compounds the pressure of managing a new baby while grappling with an uncertain financial future. This often leads employees to feel that they are unjustly treated, believing that the law should offer them better protection.
Legal Protections for Pregnant Employees
While it is true that the law safeguards pregnant employees from being fired simply due to their pregnancy, the situation is not always so clear-cut. Two key aspects of the law govern dismissals during pregnancy:
-
Pregnancy Cannot Be a Reason for Termination
Employers are legally prohibited from firing an employee because of their pregnancy, maternity leave, or for taking time off work to raise children (this is called “family status”). This means that if your employer lets you go because they learned of your pregnancy or because you are taking maternity leave, that action could be deemed pregnancy-related discrimination and potentially illegal. -
Right to Reinstatement
If you take maternity leave, your employer is legally required to reinstate you to your original position or a comparable one when you return. The law does not, however, guarantee that you will automatically return to the exact same job duties, only that they should be substantially similar.
This distinction is often misunderstood by employees and employers alike. Many people believe that if they are fired after disclosing their pregnancy or taking maternity leave, they are wrongfully dismissed or automatically entitled to be reinstated in their original position. However, while pregnancy-related discrimination is prohibited, an employer may still dismiss an employee for other legitimate reasons that are unrelated to pregnancy. This is where many employees find themselves confused and disillusioned with the legal process.
The Emotional and Financial Toll of Pregnancy-Related Terminations
The distress of receiving a termination notice while pregnant or on maternity leave is multifaceted. Pregnant employees not only face the trauma of job loss but also contend with significant financial uncertainty, particularly when they are already grappling with the financial strain of raising a child. Additionally, the abrupt termination can complicate their eligibility for maternity benefits or leave, as they may not have accrued enough insurable hours.
This situation can also have lasting consequences for future job prospects. Pregnant women who have been dismissed might experience a “chilling effect”, potentially afraid to request accommodation for pregnancy or take a maternity for fear of another termination, which further exacerbates the emotional toll. Being fired during pregnancy can also negatively affect their self-esteem and confidence as they face the challenges of parenthood and re-entering the workforce.
Understanding the Legal Framework for Dismissal
The law is not always as straightforward as it might seem. Employers may not be legally allowed to fire an employee for pregnancy-related discrimination reasons, but they can still dismiss employees for other, non-discriminatory causes, such as poor performance or restructuring. However, it is crucial for employers to document the legitimate reasons for termination to avoid any legal ramifications. For employees, this means that while they have legal protections, they must still demonstrate that their pregnancy played a role in the dismissal if they intend to pursue legal action.
If you believe you were wrongfully dismissed due to your pregnancy, it is vital to consult with an employment lawyer in Toronto. A skilled employment lawyer specializing in wrongful termination can help assess your case, determine if your dismissal was discriminatory, and advise you on the best course of action.
The Role of Employers in Pregnancy-Related Dismissals
For employers, it is essential to navigate the termination of a pregnant employee with caution. If the termination is unrelated to the pregnancy, the employer must ensure that they have valid, documented reasons for the dismissal. Failure to do so could result in costly legal consequences, including the possibility of additional severance pay, human rights damages, and other penalties. Courts have recognized the vulnerability of pregnant employees and have awarded higher severance packages and additional damages when pregnancy-related discrimination is proven.
For Employers: Best Practices for Managing Pregnant Employees
Employers should always proceed carefully when considering the termination of a pregnant employee. Here are a few key points to keep in mind:
-
Communicate Changes in Job Roles: Employers should keep employees on maternity leave informed about any changes in their position, such as company restructuring or job modifications.
-
Job Opportunities Should Be Accessible: If there are available job opportunities, employees on maternity leave should be given the same chance to apply as other employees.
-
Ensure Continuation of Benefits: Employees on maternity leave should still have access to health, dental, and other benefits typically available to active employees, as well as vacation accrual and any across-the-board salary increases.
-
Be Cautious About Job Modifications: Pregnant employees should not be reassigned to other roles unless they request it themselves. Employers should avoid treating pregnant employees differently or with less responsibility simply due to their pregnancy.
What Should You Do If You Are Fired During Pregnancy?
If you believe that your pregnancy or maternity leave played a role in your termination, the first step is to consult with an employment lawyer in Toronto. A lawyer can help you understand your rights, assess whether you have been discriminated against, and guide you through the process of pursuing legal action. You may be entitled to a severance package or additional damages if your employer’s actions were discriminatory.
It is important to document all communication with your employer regarding your pregnancy and any job-related matters. This includes emails, meeting notes, and any written correspondence. Having a clear record of events can be invaluable in proving your case if legal action becomes necessary.
Severance Package Review: What You Should Know
When facing a pregnancy-related dismissal, it is also important to review your severance package carefully. You may be entitled to more than what your employer initially offers you in the termination letter, especially if the dismissal is found to be discriminatory. A wrongful dismissal lawyer can assist in reviewing your severance package and negotiating a fair deal on your behalf. They can also ensure that you receive all the compensation you are entitled to, including damages for wrongful termination and human rights violations.
The Importance of Employment Lawyer Consultation
If you have been dismissed while pregnant or after disclosing your pregnancy, seeking legal advice is crucial. A lawyer specializing in employment law can assess your situation, help you determine whether your dismissal was unlawful, and assist you in navigating the legal system to protect your rights. Whether you need help negotiating a severance package or pursuing a wrongful dismissal claim, legal expertise is essential to ensuring you are treated fairly.
Key Takeaways:
-
Employers are prohibited from firing employees because of their pregnancy in any way whatsoever, but they can terminate employees for other reasons unrelated to pregnancy.
-
Employees on maternity leave must be reinstated to their original or comparable position, but this does not guarantee a return to the same job or duties if the job no longer exists for legitimate business reasons (such as in the event of a business restructuring or downsizing)
-
Employers should take extra care when terminating a pregnant employee and ensure they have valid, documented reasons for doing so.
-
If you believe you have been wrongfully dismissed due to your pregnancy, it is essential to seek advice from an employment lawyer in Toronto to understand your options and protect your rights.
Pregnancy should not be a reason for job loss, but the legal protections surrounding it can be complex. If you are facing dismissal during or after pregnancy, do not hesitate to reach out to a qualified wrongful dismissal lawyer to evaluate your case and explore your legal options. You have rights, and with the right legal assistance, you can ensure that they are upheld.
For many employers, termination of employment is a difficult and confusing time, especially when it comes to drafting severance packages. Therefore, in a wrongful termination of employment, it is important for employers to consult with an experienced Ontario employment lawyer for a severance package review to understand the impact of wrongful dismissal on pension plans. If you are an employer or employee needing to speak with an experienced Ontario wrongful dismissal lawyer to discuss your options and next steps on how to deal with workplace issues, call Bune Law, employment law firm in Toronto. You will review and get guidance on your severance package before you agree to sign any termination documents, and help ensure that your severance package is fair and reasonable.
