Contractor vs. Employee in Ontario: How to Classify Workers Correctly

Correctly classifying workers as either contractor vs. employee is one of the most important (and most misunderstood) issues in employment law. In Ontario, misclassification can expose businesses to serious legal and financial consequences, including unpaid wages, severance obligations, tax penalties, and wrongful dismissal claims.

For workers, classification of contractor vs. employee determines access to key rights such as termination pay, benefits, overtime, and employment insurance benefits. Because of these high stakes, both employers and workers should understand how Ontario courts assess employment status and when it may be necessary to speak with a Toronto employment lawyer.

This employment law blog article explains the differences between employees, independent contractors, and dependent contractors, outlines the legal tests used in Ontario, and highlights best practices to avoid costly mistakes.

Why Worker Classification Matters

Ontario employment law treats employees and independent contractors very differently. Employees benefit from statutory protections under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA) and the common law, while independent contractors operate as self-employed individuals with far fewer legal safeguards.

Improper classification (whether or not intentional) can result in:

• Claims for unpaid wages, overtime, and vacation pay

• Liability for termination pay and severance

• Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) penalties for unpaid payroll deductions

• Wrongful dismissal claims

• Increased scrutiny from regulatory bodies

A wrongful dismissal lawyer or employment contract lawyer can help determine whether a worker has been misclassified and what remedies may be available.

What Is an Employee Under Ontario Law?

An employee is someone who works as part of an employer’s business and is subject to the employer’s direction and control. Most traditional workplace relationships fall into this category.

Common Characteristics of Employees

While no single factor is decisive, employees often share the following traits:

• Control and supervision: The employer determines how, when, and where the work is done (such as work schedule and location)

• Integration into the business: The worker is part of the organization, not operating a separate enterprise

• Employer-provided tools and equipment: The company supplies and maintains the tools needed for the job

• Financial security: Employees are paid wages, salary, or commissions and do not bear business risk

• Exclusivity: Employees typically work for one employer and may be restricted by non-competition or non-solicitation clauses

Employees in Ontario are entitled to minimum employment standards, including vacation pay, public holiday pay, overtime, job-protected leaves, and notice or pay in lieu upon termination.

What Is an Independent Contractor?

An independent contractor is a self-employed individual or business that provides services to clients under a contract. Unlike employees, contractors run their own operations and maintain control over how their work is performed.

Common Characteristics of Independent Contractors

Independent contractors typically demonstrate:

• Autonomy: Control over work methods, scheduling, and execution

• Ownership of tools: Responsibility for purchasing, maintaining, and insuring equipment

• Financial risk and opportunity: Ability to profit or suffer losses based on business decisions

• Multiple clients: Freedom to offer services to other businesses

• No employee benefits: Responsibility for taxes, CPP contributions, and insurance

Because independent contractors are not covered by the ESA, they are generally not entitled to overtime pay, vacation pay, or statutory severance unless their contract provides otherwise.

How Ontario Courts Determine Worker Status

Ontario courts do not rely solely on job titles or written agreements, such as whether the document is called “Independent Contractor Agreement”. Instead, they assess the true nature of the working relationship using a multi-factor approach.

Key Factors Considered by the Courts

Courts commonly examine:

1. Degree of control exercised by the company

2. Ownership of tools and equipment

3. Ability to hire helpers or subcontract work

4. Financial risk and investment

5. Opportunity for profit or loss

6. Integration into the business

There is no checklist or mathematical formula. The importance of each factor depends on the specific circumstances. A contract stating “independent contractor” will not override reality if the working relationship resembles employment.

An experienced Toronto employment lawyer can analyze these factors and provide guidance on proper classification.

Employees vs. Independent Contractors: Key Differences at a Glance

While every case is unique, the following differences typically apply:

• Control: Employees are directed by the employer; true independent contractors decide how work is done

• Compensation: Employees earn wages or salary; true independent contractors are paid per project or invoice (plus HST)

• Expenses: Employees are reimbursed; true independent contractors cover their own costs (such as parking or mileage)

• Benefits: Employees receive group benefits; true independent contractors do not receive group insurance benefits

• Taxes: Employers deduct taxes for employees; true independent contractors handle their own remittances (income tax, CPP and EI benefits premiums that typically apply on employee pay cheques)

• Termination rights: Employees are entitled to notice of termination (a severance package) ; true independent contractors rely on contract terms

Misunderstanding these differences is a frequent cause of disputes and employment dispute litigation.

The Middle Ground: Dependent Contractors in Ontario

Ontario law recognizes a third category known as “dependent contractors”. These workers are not employees in the traditional sense but are economically dependent on a single client.

What Makes a Contractor “Dependent”?

Dependent contractor status often arises when:

• The worker provides services almost exclusively to one company

• The relationship is long-term and continuous

• The worker relies on the client as their exclusive or primary source of income

Courts use a two-step analysis:

1. Determine whether the worker is an employee or a contractor

2. If a contractor, assess whether they are economically dependent

High levels of exclusivity strongly support a finding of dependency.

Legal Rights of Dependent Contractors

Although dependent contractors are technically self-employed, Ontario courts often grant them protections similar to employees, particularly when it comes to termination (including a severance package upon termination).

At common law, dependent contractors are generally entitled to reasonable notice of termination, reflecting their reliance on one client. In some cases, this notice can be substantial.

Because these claims frequently involve severance disputes, consulting a severance package lawyer in Toronto is often essential.

Termination, Severance, and Wrongful Dismissal Risks

Worker classification becomes especially important when a relationship ends. Employers who mistakenly treat employees or dependent contractors as independent contractors may face:

• Claims for wrongful dismissal

• Liability for common-law reasonable notice

• ESA violations and penalties

• Retroactive severance obligations

From a worker’s perspective, being misclassified can mean losing access to termination pay, benefits, and legal remedies unless action is taken.

A wrongful dismissal lawyer can assess whether a terminated worker is entitled to severance despite being labeled a contractor.

Best Practices for Employers in Ontario

To reduce the risk of misclassification:

• Ensure contracts accurately reflect the real working relationship (such as a properly drafted employment contract)

• Avoid exercising excessive control over contractors

• Allow contractors to work for other clients and not exert significant control over their duties and responsibilities)

• Regularly review worker roles as duties evolve

• Seek advice from an employment contract lawyer before hiring

Training HR and management teams on classification rules can prevent costly disputes down the road.

What Workers Should Know

Workers should carefully review their contracts and day-to-day working conditions. If the reality of the relationship does not match the contract label, legal rights may still exist.

Workers who believe they have been misclassified should:

• Keep records of how the work is performed

• Document exclusivity and control

• Seek advice from a Toronto employment lawyer

Early legal guidance can make a significant difference in outcomes.

Final Thoughts

Correctly distinguishing between employees, independent contractors, and dependent contractors is essential under Ontario employment law. Labels alone do not determine rights, substance matters more than form.

Whether you are a business owner structuring your workforce or a worker questioning your legal status, consulting an experienced Toronto employment lawyer, severance package lawyer Toronto, or wrongful dismissal lawyer can help protect your interests and ensure compliance with the law.

Disclaimer: The content on this website and blog is not legal advice or legal opinion of any kind, and is only to provide general information. It is in no way particular to your individual case and should not be relied upon in any way. The outcome of a legal matter depends on its unique circumstances, and prior successes are not indicative of future results. No portion or use of this website or blog will establish a lawyer-client relationship with the author, this law firm or any related party. Should you require legal advice for your particular situation, please fill out the form below, or call 647-822-5492, to request an initial consultation.